Tech Minded

JWTs vs. Sessions: Which Authentication Method Should You Choose?

Aristil's photo
Aristil
·

4 min read

Introduction

Imagine you're visiting a theme park. To prove your access, there are two options:

  • A Wristband: Staff can see your privileges at a glance—no need to cross-check records.

  • A Ticket: Each time you want access, staff scan your ticket and verify it against a central database.

These options mirror JSON Web Tokens (JWTs) and Session Cookies in authentication. Let’s explore how they work, their advantages, and when to use them.

Why Authentication Matters

Authentication ensures users securely access your app. Developers often debate JWTs versus session cookies because the right method impacts:

  1. Security: Protect sensitive data from unauthorized access.

  2. Scalability: Enable seamless performance as apps grow.

  3. User Experience: Deliver smooth, hassle-free logins.

Understanding these methods helps you choose the best fit for your project.

What Are JWTs and Session Cookies?

JSON Web Tokens (JWTs)

  • Definition: Compact, self-contained tokens storing user data.

  • How It Works: The server creates and signs a token at login. The client stores the token and includes it in subsequent requests. The server verifies the token to authenticate the user.

Session Cookies

  • Definition: Cookies store a unique session ID on the client; the server keeps session data.

  • How It Works: At login, the server creates a session, linking it to a session ID stored in a cookie. The client sends the cookie on each request, and the server retrieves session data to authenticate the user.

Advantages and Disadvantages

JWTs

Advantages:

  1. Stateless: No server-side storage of user data, reducing server load.

  2. Cross-Domain Use: Works across multiple domains, ideal for microservices.

  3. Scalability: No central session store, making horizontal scaling easier.

Disadvantages:

  1. Difficult Revocation: Revoking a token mid-lifecycle requires workarounds like blacklisting.

  2. Size: Larger than session IDs, increasing bandwidth usage.

  3. Security Risks: If stolen, tokens can be misused until they expire.

Session Cookies

Advantages:

  1. Easy Revocation: Logging out invalidates the session server-side.

  2. Small Size: Minimal bandwidth impact since only the session ID is stored in the cookie.

  3. Secure by Default: Server controls session lifecycle and security.

Disadvantages:

  1. Stateful: Requires server-side storage, which can impact scalability.

  2. Domain-Specific: Cookies are tied to domains, making cross-domain use difficult.

  3. Complex Scaling: Session data must sync across multiple servers in large systems.

When to Use JWTs vs. Session Cookies

JWTs

  • Best for:

    • REST APIs and microservices needing stateless communication.

    • Scalable applications across multiple servers.

    • Cross-platform apps where clients communicate directly with APIs.

Session Cookies

  • Best for:

    • Server-rendered web apps with a centralized architecture.

    • Scenarios where immediate logout or revocation is critical.

    • Applications needing a simpler implementation with fewer moving parts.

Code Examples

JWT Example

import jwt, datetime

@app.route('/login', methods=['POST'])
def login():
    token = jwt.encode({'user': 'valid_user', 'exp': datetime.datetime.utcnow() + datetime.timedelta(hours=1)}, 'secret')
    return {'token': token}

@app.route('/protected', methods=['GET'])
def protected():
    try:
        jwt.decode(request.headers.get('Authorization'), 'secret', algorithms=["HS256"])
        return {'message': 'Access granted'}
    except:
        return {'message': 'Invalid token'}, 403

Explanation:

  1. Login: Issues a signed token with user info and expiration.

  2. Protected Route: Validates the token before granting access.

from flask import session

@app.route('/login', methods=['POST'])
def login():
    session['user'] = 'valid_user'
    return {'message': 'Logged in'}

@app.route('/protected', methods=['GET'])
def protected():
    if 'user' in session:
        return {'message': 'Access granted'}
    return {'message': 'Not logged in'}, 403

Explanation:

  1. Login: Saves the user session on the server.

  2. Protected Route: Checks if a session exists before granting access.

Best Practices

  1. Secure Tokens or Cookies: Use httpOnly cookies or encrypted local storage to prevent XSS attacks.

  2. Short Expirations: Minimize token or session duration to reduce exposure risks.

  3. Use HTTPS: Always encrypt communication to prevent interception.

Conclusion

JWTs and session cookies both excel in different scenarios:

  • Use JWTs for stateless, scalable APIs and cross-platform apps.

  • Use session cookies for server-rendered apps requiring centralized control and easy logout.

The choice depends on your app’s architecture, user needs, and scalability goals. Thoughtful implementation ensures secure, efficient, and user-friendly authentication.

  1. Jones, M. (2024). JSON Web Token (JWT) Handbook. Retrieved from JWT.io

  2. OWASP Foundation. (2024). Session Management Cheat Sheet. Retrieved from OWASP.org

  3. Flask-Security Team. (2024). Flask-Security Documentation. Retrieved from Flask-Security

  4. Real Python. (2024). Managing Authentication in Flask. Retrieved from RealPython.com